Campus Total Defence and the Role of Swedish Universities

The second invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 changed a lot of things for higher education around the world. The world of open science and free collaboration across borders, already in trouble because of the US-China rivalry, definitively ended. Security became a watchword, not just in terms of protecting sensitive research, but in terms of the actual topics researchers were being asked to engage with. The idea that knowledge existed to be in the service of the national interest, a concept mostly thought to have been left back in the Cold War, came back with a vengeance.

The switch was nowhere more of a shock than in Sweden, which managed to ride out the Cold War as a neutral country, partly because it took national defence very seriously. But for three decades, it imagined all those days were behind it. The sudden realization that Russia, a near neighbour, was in fact a predator nation bent on projecting its will by force across all its near abroad shocked the country into joining NATO, and in turn made the country have a rethink over the role of universities in a new national security environment.

One of the ideas they hit upon was something called Campus Total Defence. Partly, Campus Total Defence is a way to collaborate with the military on research, but it’s also a strategy to ensure that the population has the skill set and knowledge to survive any kind of emergency situation, and to put universities at the heart of delivering these kinds of programmes. Perhaps more interestingly, it’s a strategy that universities built on their own spontaneously and decided only to worry about who would pay for it afterwards.

With me today is one of the architects of Campus Total Defence, Johan Schnürer. He’s the former vice-chancellor of Örebro University and the chair of the Campus Total Defence steering group. In our discussion today, we talk about the shock of February 2022, how the concept of total defence is applied in Sweden, how Campus Total Defence came about, and what the future is for university-military cooperation in Sweden.

I hope you’ll enjoy it, but for now, over to Johan.


The World of Higher Education Podcast
Episode 5.10 | Campus Total Defence and the Role of Swedish Universities

Transcript

Alex Usher (AU): Johan, welcome to the show.

Johan Schnürer (JS): Thank you very much.

AU: I wanna start by talking about the history of Swedish academic institutions’ participation in national defense. During the Cold War, Sweden had… I guess, a well-armed neutrality and that required a fair amount of domestic arms production from companies like Saab and BAE.

Were there tight links between academia and the defense industry back then, back in the Cold War? What were the politics of that collaboration like?

JS: Actually, I don’t think there was really strong collaboration between the universities and the military. But after the Second World War, Sweden had organized something called the National Defense Research Organization, or FOA, and that one was quite strong and received quite a lot of research money. So many people went from university side to work with this more secretive organization.

AU: Mm-hmm. So that’s more like the French system or the Finnish system where the research is not done in universities, but rather in government laboratories or government organizations.

JS: Yeah, at that time – Sweden at that time even for a period had the ambition to create its own nuclear defense or nuclear weapons, and that of course had to be very secretive. So, it wasn’t done at universities, but there was some collaboration, mainly with the technical universities.

AU: Got it. So let me ask you about the concept of total defense. What is it? Where does that idea come from?

JS: The idea came at the end of the Second World War when Sweden realized that we had not prepared society for an all-out war. Sweden had not been in war itself since 1814, and we lost Finland in 1809. So, it’s been a long period without any conditions of war. But it was realized particularly during the First and even more during the Second World War, that we needed to mobilize all of society into the concept of total defense, meaning that you had a strong military, but in order to provide society at large with all that it needed, you also need a strong civil defense. You need to organize psychological defense, economic defense, et cetera. And that started at the end of the Second World War and became a very large feature of Swedish national life until the end of the Cold War.

AU: What did it require Swedes to do?

JS: You had a duty to report… we still have that actually. At that time between 16 and 65, today between …from you are 16 until you are 70, actually. That you could contribute either in the military. We had the Cold War, we had about 850,000 men under weapon. And we also had people that were assigned to defend their workplace.

We had people assigned to man hospitals, to man bakeries, to man different critical industries and transport infrastructure. So about one quarter of the grown-ups in Sweden were drafted into a total defense system.

AU: Hmm. And was that maintained after the end of the Cold War? My impression is that a lot of the discussion in Sweden these days is Swedes beating themselves up about having been too casual during the ’90s and 2000s and maybe lax about defense. So, what happened to total defense between, say 1989 and 2022?

JS: The civil defense part of it totally evaporated. It was totally lost. Some infrastructure sharps, such as bomb shelters, were left and not destroyed. There are bomb shelters for about 7.5 millions of the 11 million people in Sweden that were built during that time. But the rest, all the preparations, all the stocks of diesel fuels, fertilizer, food, hospital material were all gone.

Quite a bit of it went to the new Baltic States to support them in different ways. But it was totally reduced to zero, and the military shrank to 10% of its former strength. Now, this has been related to the end of history, Francis Fukuyama. But in reality, it was Sweden and much of the Western world taking a holiday from history.

We thought everything would be sunshine, and [it] turned out not to be true. So, we have to rethink it and do it in a modern way. And one ironic thing is that Finland, who had had a much tougher situation during the Second World War and after, they learned from the Swedish total defense concept and built up stocks and preparedness different ways, and they kept it.

So, we know how to relearn from the Finns, but we’re good friends, so it works.

AU: So on February 24th, 2022, Russia invaded Ukraine. In Sweden, that set off a chain of events which resulted in the country choosing to abandon its longtime position of neutrality and to start down the route to joining NATO. But it also made the country serious about total defense again, didn’t it?

So what steps were taken to revive total defense, and how quickly could it be put in place?

JS: It is advancing rapidly – I should say now, the last two, three years. We have now an agency for civil defense and a minister for civil defense that is sort of in parallel to the minister for military defense. They work in tandem. And we have [been] starting to rebuild and retrain people with different critical skills.

And you have people that are getting this call for duty or preparedness within their ordinary working place, that they should keep certain critical operations going. So, we are moving fast now, and we have increased. In 2022, you had approximately 1.4% of the gross domestic product went to defense-related issues or expenses. Now it’s 2.8%, and we are aiming for 5% – 3.5% for military and 1.5% for civil defense-related issues.

AU: That’s a very quick increase, and I imagine a lot of other things have to be cut for that to happen. So, is it popular in Sweden or no?

JS: It’s understood that it’s necessary. All the political parties from the very left to the very, very right, all of them agree on this. That it’s not an issue. An issue is how to manage the funding. For the time being, we are borrowing a little bit for the infrastructure part of it. But we will have to make some tough choices later on. But on the other hand, we have a very low … the loan situation of Sweden is quite different from most countries. It’s about 35% or 30% of the gross domestic income, and the economy is growing, which makes it easier. But, it is understood by the absolute majority that this is a necessity considering what’s happening in Ukraine.

AU: Okay, so Johan, let’s now talk about what you’re best known for, which is Total Campus Defense. What’s Total Campus Defense? How did it come about? What are its origins?

JS: The origin is a meeting on the political week that is a dear Swedish tradition in Almedalen in Gotland in the summer of 2022. Myself and the rector for the National Defense College, we realized that neither the politicians nor the military nor other authorities had thought about the role of universities in the total defense concept.

And we organized a working group within the National Swedish Rectors’ Conference, where we started to discuss how can we contribute. And we arranged that group in such a way that we had representatives from all the six civil defense regions of Sweden from north to south, which turned out to be critical in order to get engagement from whole of Sweden and all of the political parties and the county governors, et cetera.

So, we worked during 2023 with developing this concept, and we met with ministers. We met with their closest coworkers, and a particularly critical meeting was in early 2024. And then we managed to get some support from a research funding agency. And then in the September of 2024, we got government funding to develop this, which was followed up by more government funding for the research item things.

And we have managed to maintain this positive momentum by also including in this working group and now the steering group for Campus Total Defense, the person that is responsible for research and development of the armed forces and a person from the National Authority for Civil Defense and student representatives.

So, this has developed, but that was the start – a realization that politicians had not thought about universities and maybe had a very naive idea that if war should happen, we will send home the students, and then war would be over in two weeks. Seeing what’s happening in the Ukraine, that is not the case.

AU: Well, let’s talk about the teaching and learning offerings that are there right now. I mean, I’ve been through the website, I’ve looked at it, and some of what’s there, you know, sort of looks like regular university offerings. But other things look like micro-credentials basically. They’re sort of short course certificate kinds of things. What kinds of courses mainly are offered through these? And how widely are the courses taken up?

JS: Courses on issues like leadership and cybersecurity are widely taken up by a very large number of students. And the idea is actually to have these micro-credential, as you call them, in order to facilitate for people who want to improve their knowledge of the total defense system, people that are working in regional or national agencies, et cetera.

We also have specific courses that are paid for by agencies or by industry, and not all of them are on the webpage. But then we want to highlight what the universities really are doing that connects with total defense. And as we are academics, of course, you think, you know that everyone thinks that his or her particular topic is the one topic. So, we have to be a bit restrictive.

AU: Do the civil defense agencies, you know, the various ones, do they tell you which of your courses they think are useful and which are not? Do they encourage you to do more of some things and less of others?

JS: It’s a dialogue, and as I said, we had the National Civil Defense Agency has been represented all along. So there’s continuous dialogue with the working group on education on this, what should be prioritized.

AU: When the idea first came up, you know, presumably you’re offering these courses how did government react? You know, because often when something like this starts, the first question is, how do you pay for it? And presumably institutions and government both would’ve wanted the other one to pay for it.

How did that discussion start with the government, and how did government funding eventually emerge from the discussions?

JS: I’m not quite sure about the proper term, but what would be the closest coworker with a minister at the federal level? What would be that?

AU: So a deputy minister, then the permanent secretary? 

JS: Yeah. Something like the deputy minister. We had a very serious discussions with two deputy ministers from the Ministry of Defense and one from Ministry of Education early on in January 2024, where we realized that they were really positive.

They saw this as a splendid initiative, really, from the universities themself, and they even said that they saw it as a bottom-up initiative. As we were three university rectors that had came up with this – this is not the case at our universities, that when rectors suggest something, it’s a bottom-up initiative, but for the government it was.

So, they were really pleased that universities wanted to do this, not that it would be forced on the universities to do it, because that could potentially create another reaction. So, we got this amount of starting money, 17 million crowns per year, to do different things and including planning for courses, et cetera.

There is a lot of money within the system now. As I mentioned, we have increased the budget and the Agency for Civil Defense have quite a substantial budget for education, and also the regional authorities have that one. So, they ask us for specific courses that then are given at the regional level. So far this has not been a major problem.

AU: What about the research side now? So, how has Total Campus Defense changed relationships between universities and defense agencies? You know, you said earlier that there’s not a long history of that kind of collaboration. What’s been born out of the collaboration on the research side to date?

JS: I think Campus Total Defence has acted as a catalyst for making researcher, scientists aware in different way, both waking up to what’s happening. I mean, it’s obvious in the media, but you can still sort of hide your head in the sand. So, what we did in 2024 was that we organized a conference where we had asked all universities to come in with suggestions for important topics that they thought would be useful to, develop and support the Total Defence concept.

And we got a massive amount, I think 600 suggestions, that were then grouped into 12 larger thematic areas. And we now have these 12 running with a bit of seed money from Campus Total Defence. And the areas range from sort of obvious things, technology and military defense, AI and drones, space and the Arctic, logistics, and resource availability, but also things like culture in crisis and war, which was one of the first areas, which we think is absolutely essential to understand how can education, how can research help us to develop resilience.

And I was particularly moved by the visit by the Ukrainian ambassador who told us how the Russians are systematically destroying the cultural heritage of Ukraine. And we also, when the war started, how singing and singing across the internet globally was part of building resilience and strength.

But we also have programs on democracy and peace. We hope for a bright future. So, there are people doing research on how can you come back after war. And of course, issues like leadership and communication in crisis. So, we have now 12 of these areas, each one coordinated by one university and with 5 to 15 other universities participating.

So, we have started a large movement across Sweden, 37 universities and polytechs or higher educational institutes are now participating. And all of them also participate with total defense actors around their campus site. So, we have catalyzed and there are lots of things happening now, and there is also more money for research in defense-related areas. And we have Campus Total Defense have organized meetings with all the main funding organizations. We will do that every year now.

AU: What pushback has there been, if any, to this? I mean, academics often, you know, they feel quite skittish and reluctant about seeing their work turned towards military ends. Has there been any pushback around those kinds of issues?

JS: Very limited, actually. Surprisingly limited. And I actually, I spoke to all the German university rectors and they asked the same questions. They thought it would be very difficult in Germany to do something similar. But people realize that this is a necessity. We have a country not far from where we live, which is under attack, and has been so for a long time.

And I think, perhaps also, that we said from the beginning that this is not only a question of technology and military use, it’s also a question of sustainability and resilience in society at large. That was a good thing, I think actually. And we said no one will ever be asked to do research on military things unless they don’t want to.

It’s part of academic freedom. But there will be people doing it, and that’s also part of academic freedom. So, there’s been very limited setback. There’s been a little bit of usual academic competition for funds and for space and there’s… et cetera. But generally, people also reflected by the political situation that all the parties in the Swedish parliament support Ukraine. All the parties support the buildup of the total defense again. So that helps.

AU: I think everyone’s starting to realize we’re not going back to a pre-2022 world anytime soon. Like, we had 75 – 80 years of a post-war settlement, and now we’ve got something different. And so, what you’ve been doing with Campus Total Defense has been a great start, but presumably it’s got a long way to go.

Like, the problems that it’s designed to solve are not gonna go away very soon. So how do you see the organization or the network developing? Like, 15 years from now, what else do you think you’ll be able to do on top of what you’re doing now?

JS: I think first, hopefully, that the war in Ukraine will end, but the mentality within the Russian government will probably not end, so we have to be prepared. I also think that we need to do even more with issues related to energy sovereignty, that we can’t be dependent on fossil fuels that change the climate, and for a large part comes from very unpleasant regimes.

So, making a more sustainable society, making a society that makes better use of resources. We are wasting phosphate, nitrogen, et cetera … that could be used in agriculture and instead polluting the ocean and our seas. And all of this and also dealing with aspect of a changed climate, preparing for pandemics, et cetera, will make us better prepared.

And hopefully we have learned to work in a different way. It’s even been said that in an innovation-thirsty country, that Campus Total Defense is an innovation in itself in linking different universities working together, which they would never have done unless we had started this initiative. And I hope that will continue.

AU: Johan Schnürer, thanks so much for joining us today.

JS: Thank you for having me.

AU: And it just remains for me to thank our excellent producers, Noah Arney and Samantha Pufek, and of course you, our listeners and readers, for joining us. If you have any questions or comments about this week’s episode, or if you have suggestions for future ones, don’t hesitate to get in touch with us at podcast@higheredstrategy.com.

Join us next week when our guest will be Andrée Silsuck. Andrée is a senior advisor at the European University Association and an independent consultant, and she’s gonna be joining us to talk about financial developments in French higher education, and in particular, the results of the Assises du financement. Bye for now.

*This podcast transcript was generated using an AI transcription service with limited editing. Please forgive any errors made through this service. Please note, the views and opinions expressed in each episode are those of the individual contributors, and do not necessarily reflect those of the podcast host and team, or our sponsors.

Share:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *