France: Access and Parcoursup

Why have French lycéens and university students been in the streets for weeks? There are many reasons, of course – school underfunding being the principal one – but the demand that really has resonance across both groups is the demand to abolish “Parcoursup”, which is kind of a cross between the Ontario University Application System and Schoolfinder.com. Why would something so innocuous-sounding attract such opprobrium? Read on.

To really understand Parcoursup, you need to first grasp how the French higher education system is structured and what exactly happens to students after they finish secondary school (lycée) and receive their baccalauréat.  At the pinnacle of the system are the grandes écoles, places like Polytechnique and l’École normale supérieur, which normally cannot be accessed directly from secondary school, but instead require two years of preparatory school (prépas) and examinations. Getting into a good prépas – many of which are located in lycées – is usually considered the pinnacle of achievement post-bac. After that, there are a lot of specialized schools in subjects like health and architecture. There are also a lot of private schools, often but not exclusively in fields related to business. 

Public universities in many ways occupy a place just below all of that – not least because they are largely absent from fields like engineering, business, architecture and nursing. And they co-exist with Instituts Universitaires de Technologie (IUTs), semi-autonomous units within universities that mostly teach applied programs and are more selective, have smaller class sizes, and better labour market outcomes. And finally, there are 2-year vocational certificates known as BTS (brevet de technicien supérieur) which are delivered in a variety of settings, including lycées.

If you are confused by all of this, you are not alone. France’s post-secondary system is arguably the most complicated in the entire world. Certainly, one of the most difficult to encapsulate. This is one of the reasons that Parcoursup has such a heavy dose of schoolfinder included in it. But one key part of the system is really simple to understand: if you have a baccalauréat, you have a legal right to a place in post-bac education. I’ll spare you a history lesson here, but basically, what that has meant in practice is that grandes écoles and IUTs have been permitted to be selective (as have privates, provided demand exceeds capacity), while universities – at least at the undergraduate level – have not.

The problem with not being selective is that while, on the whole, university capacity is somewhat elastic, capacity constraints at the program level are much more binding. Being non-selective in medicine, for instance, would create unbelievable cost and capacity issues. So, what the French did, historically, was to allow everyone into special first-year programs and then brutally cull numbers before second year. This is accessibility, of a sort, but not anything North Americans would recognize as fair.

Briefly, starting around 2000, the French tried another solution to oversubscription: namely, a combination of localization and lotteries. If a program was oversubscribed, a computer would use a variety of tie-breakers to bring the numbers down to what a program could accommodate: proximity of residence, an individual’s preference ranking of the program, and the student’s marital status (married students being assumed to be less mobile and therefore more deserving place). And if none of that worked to bring numbers down – then they would resort to random selection.

This was an imperfect solution for a couple of reasons. Many, mostly on the right, thought lotteries were anti-meritocratic. Also, everyone outside Paris got annoyed because the “regional preference” idea meant that Parisian students got first pick at the most popular and prestigious universities. And, of course, changing the rationing criteria doesn’t solve the problem of a system in which demand for places – at least in prestigious institutions/fields – exceeded demand.

And so, in 2018, France introduced the Parcoursup system. This principally changed two things.  The first was that for the first time, institutions were allowed to select students: students applied through the Parcoursup website to up to ten programs, their dossiers were forwarded to universities, and then each institution applied its own criteria to select students. For the most part, they use secondary school grades; occasionally they use factors like the high school the student is applying from. In other words, it’s almost exactly like the Ontario University Application Centre’s website. The second was that, for the first time, the official entry system had a whole other set of functions bolted on with respect to “orientation” (this is the schoolfinder.com bit), which are largely about trying to get less-than-stellar students to not apply to prestigious institutions but rather to ones which provide a “better fit” for them. The theory here being that at least some of the previous overcrowding was because students not picking the “right” program rather than a failure of organization or funding.

Anyways, long story short: in the Parcoursup era there still aren’t enough spaces for everyone in the programs they want. No surprise there: no system in the world provides this. It’s not just a question of funding, but of rigidity; it’s hard to shift to meet changing demand when your faculty aren’t tenured and, for the most part, aren’t capable of switching disciplines. Governments can bang away at this problem a bit, much in the way the governments of Ontario and Alberta have done (money for new seats, but only in specified high-demand areas), but it’s a moving target.

But again, that’s not primarily what students are protesting. They keep going on about how selection via Parcoursup is “unfair” and “opaque”.  At the margin, there are things that could make Parcoursup better: ranking one’s choices, for instance (no longer possible since 2018 for no good reason); programs could publish what their minimum acceptance grade was the year previous year, rather than just say, as they currently do, “here are the criteria we look at and here is how we decide close calls” (which they have all been legally required to do since 2023). 

There are also some potentially darker results to Parcoursup reform. Some suggest that a “fairer” and “more transparent” system would rely solely on baccaluaréat exam results rather than the current high school grades, a move which would require moving the bac exams up by a couple of months (indeed, this is Marine Le Pen’s position). The Ministry has already examined this possibility and found that it would privilege richer students. This accords with almost everything we know about meritocracy and high stakes exams in every other country in the world too. What replaces Parcoursup might be a lot worse than students think (but then again, if you’re one of those bourgeois Parisian kids out protesting these last few weeks, such a scenario might work out quite well for you).

In any event: the French admissions system could certainly be improved around the margins. But fundamentally, Parcoursup isn’t the problem. The problem is that in a system of limited means, there is always rationing. In most of the world, we’ve learned to live with that. The French system is actually pretty close to what we have here in Ontario, and no one here would ever dream of having a protest against it. In France, however, no matter how rationing is attempted, no one seems to like it very much. 

Regardless of who wins Presidential elections, it seems Parcoursup will be replaced by something else in 2028. But getting rid of Parcoursup doesn’t get rid of the twin problems of a sufficient supply of “in-demand” places and the mechanics of rationing.  Expect the new system to be on the end of student protests, too. 

Share:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *