Re-thinking Government Relations

In the wake of the HESA Towers coverage of the largely disastrous November 5 budget, a number of people have pushed me to expand on my thoughts about what’s gone wrong with our sector’s lobbying efforts and how to put it right. Consider today’s blog my response to this challenge.

So, first of all, I should clarify what I meant when I said “the sector is catastrophically bad at lobbying”. Many people who I have spoken to assumed that what I was suggesting was specifically that peak representative bodies located in Ottawa – Universities Canada, CICan, the Canadian Association of University Teachers, etc. – were guilty of poor performance with respect to their primary task of day-to-day of government lobbying. But that’s not quite what I was getting at. This may or may not be the case; I don’t monitor these organizations close enough to have an informed opinion, really. The thing to remember about these peak bodies is that they are all membership organizations. If these organizations are executing poorly, it may simply be that the marching orders they have been given by their members and boards aren’t very good. That is to say, it may not be the execution that’s the problem, but the strategy itself.

When looking for money, universities tend to fall back on two simple themes. Very roughly, they are:

1)      We are institutions. Strong institutions make for strong societies/economies. Give us money to make us stronger.

2)      The knowledge economy is good. Research and advanced education are good for the knowledge economy. Give us money and we will make the knowledge economy better.

The problem with the first of these is that it’s not clear to me how many governments actually believe the first of these anymore. Oh sure, everyone nods at institutions – motherhood and apple pie stuff – but I get the sense that most governments have become so transactional that, in practice, appeals to support institutions are just neither here nor there. Institutions have no superior claim to resources than any other interest group competing for money. Governments want to know what you’ve done for them lately and how you can help them in the future.

But universities prefer to avoid making commitments like this to governments: or, at least, they prefer not to work through lobbying bodies to make commitments. As a result, when peak bodies like Universities Canada try to argue for funding, they sound pretty weak. Take UC’s May 2026 budget submission for instance, which I summarize below.

ThemeWhat Universities Asked ForWhat Universities Offer in Return
Compete for TalentMore money to hire foreign scientistsSome generalized improvement in export development
Equip Canadians with SkillsInclude universities in various skills initiative?? genuinely hard to tell
Harness University Research for National PrioritiesI have read this bit several times and am unable to work out what the ask is. It seems to be about making universities more able to work on defence/dual-use issuesIn theory, better HQP for defence-related research
Tax ReliefIncrease GST/HST rebate to 100%Nothing

Now, you can take the position that everything Universities Canada asks for is right and good in and of itself and shouldn’t require a “transaction”. Fair enough – but it you know the government that you’re dealing with is transactional, this is pretty weak. The strategy is not so much to bargain, but to gesticulate towards areas where universities wants and government priorities are at least vaguely entwined and point to them and say “Look, a pretext for you to funnel money to us!”  Which is fairly underwhelming, to be honest.

To repeat what I said earlier: I don’t think you can blame Universities Canada HQ in Ottawa for this, really. I mean, even if they’d wanted to be more transactional, what could it have offered on behalf of its members? Nothing. Their members don’t want to be tied down to specifics, and they definitely don’t want to be corralled into jointly agreeing to anything. And indeed, it’s hard to fault them for doing so – for universities to be able to make strong commitments to government would require management having a lot more power over faculty than it actually does. In a world where you have to give a little to get a little, this is just a basic structural weakness inherent to the nature of universities that we all have to accept.

But let’s come back to the earlier point about the assumption that “the knowledge economy is good, and universities are crucial to the knowledge economy”. Almost all of university GR comms takes the first part of that sentence as read and therefore focuses on reassuring government and the public about how crucial universities are to the knowledge economy. This assumption is, I am increasingly convinced, quite simply wrong. In fact, almost no one in Canada thinks the knowledge economy is important. I urge you to check out this little piece from my pal Andrew Parkin which shows in devastating detail the extent to which Canadians think energy, natural resources and agriculture are Canada’s “strong” industries, but also that they will continue to be so into the future. It’s not even close.

So, ask yourself: if Canadians so clearly believe that the future is natural resources, why would any politician divert money towards a clearly extraneous set of institutions like universities? The obvious corollary here is that the university sector is fighting the wrong fight. The battle needs to move upstream. Universities need to stop talking about themselves; instead, they need to talk about why a knowledge-intensive future for the country is better than a natural resources-based future. 

There is a very clear model for how to do this, and it comes from the Netherlands. A few months ago on the podcast, I interviewed Marcel Levi, the head of something called “The Knowledge Coalition” or Kenniscoalitie. It brings together universities and polytechnics, university medical centres, the country’s national academy, the organization for health research and development, and various employers’ groups to talk about what is necessary for the knowledge economy to thrive and regularly lay out plans for how to make the country more hospitable to knowledge-generating industries. They aren’t always listened to, but sometimes they can be very influential; many of their recommendations ended up in the new coalition agreement that emerged after the last election.

If they were smart, Canadian universities and colleges would do the same. They would put together a wide coalition that is militantly pro-science, pro-knowledge sector, and pro-inclusive growth. It would find allies from the private sector and the hospital sector. They would argue relentlessly for the kinds of policies that would turn Canada from a laggard to a leader in the intangibles economy.

That’s what they should do, anyway. They won’t, because universities are far too conservative. But here’s something they could do instead: they could start offering visions of – and roadmaps to – a knowledge-intensive future that Canadians and their politicians can get excited about. A Universities Canada (or U-15, or CAUT, or whoever) ask for more research money and less HST? Boring and self-serving. A Universities Canada (or whoever) ask for a smarter, whizzier, richer Canada?  One not so tied to precisely the goods that are vulnerable to tariffs? Now that might just get people’s attention. 

It would at least have the virtue of never having been tried.

Share:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *