Higher Education Strategy Associates

Getting a Global Common Data Set Off the Ground

How could a global common data set (CDS) come into existence? Here are a few considerations:

In addition to improving accuracy and comparability, common data sets come into existence for two reasons. The first is to save money by limiting the number of data requests flying in from every yahoo wanting to create his or her own ranking. The second, less obvious reason, is that the creation of an open-access data platform lowers the barriers to entry for new rankers. It’s a way of busting data monopolies.

For that reason, it’s unlikely that a commercial entity is going to lead the way, except as a contract provider of technical assistance. The real impetus is going to have to come from institutions themselves. But which institutions?

An initiative backed by schools from a single country or region probably wouldn’t get very far, which is why I’m not sure U-Multirank is the way forward. But formal global bodies aren’t the answer either. IAU and UNESCO have too many members wishing to play King Canute to the rising tide of rankings for them to be an option.

Ad-hoc coalitions of institutions are possible: if you were to throw together some interested IR people from (say) Australia, Canada, Singapore and Norway, you could see it happening. But structure matters in collaborations, which is why a meeting of minds at two or three of the big existing alliances like the International Alliance of Research Universities or Universitas 21 would seem like the likeliest source of a successful project. In terms of optics, locating project management outside the U.S. and U.K. would be preferable.

The keys to success will be flexibility and cost-effectiveness. If a Global CDS asks for too much data from its members, or asks for data which is too difficult to obtain or manipulate, it will never catch on. Things like research output, student survey results and more exotic ideas like “artistic output” need to be sidelined for the moment (or at least relegated to optional data fields outside the “core”).

The important thing will be the core variables: money, students, faculty. Those are things anyone can count, but which for various reasons are compiled differently around the globe. If these elements can be well-defined and well-managed, the resulting success will bring in new members and, over time, an appetite to increase the project’s scope.

Basically, creating a genuinely globally CDS is a ton of work. Thomson-Reuters or U-Multirank would have to get someone really ticked off for people to think it worth the investment. But the proliferation of university alliances are reducing the transaction cost of this kind of collaborative work every day. This could come sooner than you think.

This entry was posted in Data, Worldwide PSE and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Getting a Global Common Data Set Off the Ground

  1. David Baker says:

    I think we are further advanced in this effort than some would believe. The non-profit standards development organization I lead, The Consortia Advancing Standards in Research Administration (CASRAI), was founded in Canada in 2006 through the initiative of NSERC and SSHRC and has since attracted participation from most federal and provincial funders and a growing list of universities – including 3 of the G5 so far. Recent partnerships in the UK, EU and the US have us on a very good start to a sustainable approach to achieving a common data set. In fact, the CASRAI open data dictionary is not only gaining momentum in Canada, the UK and EU, but it is also a basis of the upcoming ScienCV initiative among the federal research funders in the US. Recent new joins in Germany and Denmark bode well for participation from those countries as well. Our members, board and executive network are very proud of the progress we are making. I encourage you to look into what we are doing and the opportunities for a common data-set in the common global dictionary for research this community is already building. You can get updates at http://casrai.org/updates

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We encourage constructive debate. Therefore, all comments are moderated. While anonymous or pseudonymous comments are permitted, those that are inflammatory or disrespectful may be blocked.